The Uncomfortable Art of Wanting Someone Else’s Life

/ˈenvi/ | noun

Dictionary definition: A feeling of discontent or longing arising from another person’s possessions, achievements, advantages, or circumstances.

AJ’s interpretation: The curious habit of measuring our unfinished chapters against someone else’s published pages, then wondering why our own story feels inadequate.

---

The Grass Was Never the Problem

An Original Free Verse Poem by AJ Gabriel

I saw your photograph yesterday.

A beautiful house,
a remarkable view,
a table dressed for celebration,
and a caption about dreams
finally coming true.

I was happy for you.

At least,
that was my first thought.

My second was less generous.

I wondered how you managed
to arrive so quickly
at a place I had been trying
to reach for years.

And there it was.

That unpleasant little feeling
I would rather not introduce
at a dinner party.

Envy.

Such an embarrassing guest,
especially when it arrives
without an invitation
and begins inspecting
everything missing from your life.

Suddenly,
my perfectly ordinary afternoon
seemed terribly inadequate.

The room looked smaller.
My achievements appeared modest.
Even the cup of coffee beside me
had somehow become
a disappointing life decision.

I began counting.

Your victories.
My delays.

Your milestones.
My unfinished plans.

The opportunities you received,
the chances I had missed,
and all the imaginary deadlines
I had apparently failed to meet.

For a moment,
I forgot something rather important.

I knew nothing
about the mornings before that photograph.

The disappointments
that never reached the camera.
The compromises behind the celebration.
The private worries
that might still exist
beyond the frame.

And perhaps
you knew just as little about mine.

Still,
I sat there comparing
two entirely different lives
as though we had been handed
the same instructions
and expected to finish
at precisely the same time.

How absurd.

As if happiness
were a limited edition,
as if success
came with numbered tickets,
as if your good fortune
had somehow reduced
the possibilities available to me.

I closed the photograph.

Not because I resented you,
but because I finally recognised
what the feeling was trying
rather clumsily to tell me.

I wanted something.

Not necessarily your house,
your journey,
or even your particular happiness.

I wanted the reassurance
that my efforts
were taking me somewhere.

I wanted to believe
that being behind
was not the same
as being left out.

And perhaps
that was the most uncomfortable part.

You had done nothing wrong.

Your happiness
was not an accusation.

Your achievement
was not a verdict
on everything I had yet to accomplish.

So I made another cup of coffee.

The room was still the same size.
My plans were still unfinished.
The future remained
remarkably uncooperative.

But the afternoon
no longer felt like a competition.

Somewhere,
you were enjoying
a moment you had worked for.

And here,
in a different house,
on a different page,
I still had a life
that deserved my attention.

The grass, I realised,
had never been the problem.

I had simply spent
too much time
looking over the fence
to notice
what needed tending
on my own side.

— AJ Gabriel

The Dictionary of Human Feelings | Entry 004

---

A Note From AJ

I think envy is one of those emotions people are reluctant to admit experiencing. It’s much easier to discuss happiness, gratitude, or even sadness than to acknowledge that someone else’s good fortune has occasionally made us question our own circumstances. Perhaps that’s because envy comes with an uncomfortable reputation. We associate it with bitterness, resentment, or wishing someone else would fail. Yet feeling envious doesn’t automatically mean we want another person to lose what they’ve achieved.

Sometimes, envy simply exposes something we want for ourselves. A friend’s promotion might remind us of our own career ambitions. Someone’s beautiful home might make us reconsider our living situation. A photograph of a holiday might awaken a desire to explore somewhere new. The difficulty begins when we stop recognising those desires as our own and start treating another person’s achievements as evidence of our inadequacy.

Social media certainly makes comparison convenient. We can witness dozens of milestones before breakfast, from engagements and graduations to new houses, successful businesses, and carefully photographed holidays. What we rarely see is the complete story behind them. And to be fair, most of us aren’t exactly volunteering photographs of our unpaid bills, unsuccessful attempts, or the laundry we’ve been ignoring since Tuesday.

I’ve also realised that two feelings can exist together. I can genuinely celebrate someone’s achievement while privately wishing I had reached a similar milestone. Those emotions aren’t necessarily contradictions. What matters is how I respond to them.

Someone else’s success is information about their journey, not a judgement on mine.

These days, I find it more useful to ask myself what an uncomfortable comparison is revealing. Is it something I genuinely want, or something society has convinced me I should have achieved by now? Would I still desire it if nobody else knew about it? And perhaps most importantly, am I willing to do what it takes to pursue it?

Sometimes the answers are surprisingly revealing.

After all, there’s very little sense in admiring somebody else’s garden while neglecting the plants you’ve already bought.

AJ Gabriel
Occasionally checking the fence, but minding my own garden.